If XAI are to become social XAI, XAI methods must have capabilities enabling them to ‘extract’ information about the underlying AI model and to generate explanatory content based on that information. In a dialog between explainer and explainee, the explanans presented in every explanation move have to relate to each other understandably and coherently in order to remain trustworthy. This signifies that the generated explanantia have to be consistent—independently of what question is answered by each explanans, in what modality, in what vocabulary, and at what level of abstraction. Moreover, it is advantageous to be able to provide a rich palette of different kinds of explanantia in order to be able to have a fluent dialog in which the explanantia can be generated and adapted to the context, the explainee, feedback, reactions during the interaction with the explainee, and so forth. This chapter attempts to identify relevant questions that an explainee might ask during an explanatory dialog, and it assesses to what extent different XAI methods are capable of addressing these questions in a coherent way. The Contextual Importance and Utility (CIU) method is used to illustrate how an XAI method can generate explanantia for most of the identified questions. CIU also provides a flexibility in how explanatory content is generated that makes it possible to create a meaningful dialog with the explainee.