Liberation in Wittgenstein and Madhyamaka Buddhism
摘要
This paper argues in favour of continuities between the philosophy of Wittgenstein and the Madhyamaka of Nāgārjuna, identifying not only methodological affinities but also a shared vision of philosophy as a liberatory praxis, enabling a radical form of freedom. In our view, neither philosopher posits any doctrines, philosophical theories or once-and-for-all claims. Instead, both Wittgenstein and Nāgārjuna aim to liberate us from disquieting pictures or ways of seeing. This study represents a new understanding of the continuities between Wittgenstein and Madhyamaka, rejecting not only the old paradigms of ineffability and anti-metaphysical readings, but also the notion that the scope of Wittgenstein and Nāgārjuna’s liberation should be seen as discontinuous. In different ways, we claim that their methods aim to affect a gestalt shift or transformative experience, thereby loosening the grip of fixations and preconceptions that cause us tension and suffering. We claim that both philosophers offer a form of salvation that goes beyond simply dissolving problems associated with philosophical problems, but addresses confusions anyone is susceptible to. This involves a radical reinterpretation of both the target of Wittgenstein’s liberatory method and the role and status of Nāgārjuna’s non-dualist description of ‘that-ness’ (tattva).