Nigeria, the most populous black African nation, has undergone seven consecutive quadrennial general elections administered by the Independent National Electoral Commission (INEC) from 1999 to 2023. Despite these electoral exercises, scholarly studies, and reports from election observers, reveal that the Nigerian electoral system consistently faces widespread corruption and malpractices. These malpractices encompass various issues such as vote buying, underage voting, bribery of electoral officials and security personnel, multiple voting, ballot box stuffing, purchasing party agents for anti-party activities, and election rigging. Several challenges, including concerns about election integrity, the independence of the election management body, legal and institutional frameworks, enforcement of electoral laws, voter apathy, and the integration of Information and Communication Technology (ICT), have been central themes in numerous electoral reform efforts and recommendations made by non-state actors. These reform efforts are intended to promote democratic elections and contribute to the consolidation of democracy in Nigeria. This chapter critically examines the effectiveness of electoral reforms in addressing election fraud and malpractices in Nigeria, with a specific focus on the 2023 general elections. Unlike previous studies that have focused on the reasons, dimensions, and implementation of electoral reforms, as well as their impact on public trust, this chapter examines specific areas where past and current electoral reforms have either mitigated or failed to curb the menace of electoral fraud in Nigeria. Utilising a qualitative approach, the study relies on secondary data from relevant literature, including reports from local and international election observers, media coverage of elections, and the author’s personal observations. The essay explains that the success of electoral reforms hinges not only on legislative changes but more crucially on the commitment of all stakeholders to cultivate a culture of electoral integrity within the democratic process.