This chapter delves into the profound and complex nature of suicide, reflecting on Goethe’s assertion that each individual and era must grapple with it anew. It questions whether self-destructiveness stems from an underlying psychopathology or external forces, or if it is an intrinsic human potential exacerbated, but not determined, by contemporary societal pressures. Highlighting Norway’s troubling suicide statistics, the discussion underscores the necessity of a mature conversation about our death wishes, moving beyond mere numbers and towards a humanized and existential understanding. The critique of the ‘zero vision for suicide’ reveals its potential to dehumanize and simplify the depths of those struggling with suicidal thoughts. The chapter advocates for non-pathological approaches, emphasizing the socio-political and structural roots of despair, as opposed to the reductionist biomedical paradigm. It argues for a shift towards a more holistic and dynamic understanding of suicidality, recognizing the individual’s autonomy and the societal conditions contributing to deaths of despair. Ultimately, it calls for a collective effort to address the ontological incompleteness of human existence, promoting dignity and support in navigating the profound burden of radical human freedom that our existence is.