This chapter briefly sketches the general concept of integrative promise, describing it as a pattern of invocation of explanatory virtues: in particular, integration, stringency, opportunism, and appeals to non-epistemic values. First, I defend the choice of the somewhat unusual term “explanatory virtue,” by comparison with appeals to other, more classic accounts of theoretical virtues, particularly those of Thomas Kuhn. I then situate integrative promise with respect to a number of other existing philosophical literatures which have treated similar subjects. Especially important is the concept of pursuit-worthiness, which has already been the topic of a significant amount of philosophical discussion. I also describe the relationship between integrative promise and the widely recognized theoretical virtues of fruitfulness and scope, and Mayo’s concept of severe testing.

错误:搜索内容不能为空,请输入英文关键词
错误:关键词超出字数限制,请精简
高级检索

Virtues and Pursuit-Worthiness

  • Charles H. Pence

摘要

This chapter briefly sketches the general concept of integrative promise, describing it as a pattern of invocation of explanatory virtues: in particular, integration, stringency, opportunism, and appeals to non-epistemic values. First, I defend the choice of the somewhat unusual term “explanatory virtue,” by comparison with appeals to other, more classic accounts of theoretical virtues, particularly those of Thomas Kuhn. I then situate integrative promise with respect to a number of other existing philosophical literatures which have treated similar subjects. Especially important is the concept of pursuit-worthiness, which has already been the topic of a significant amount of philosophical discussion. I also describe the relationship between integrative promise and the widely recognized theoretical virtues of fruitfulness and scope, and Mayo’s concept of severe testing.