This chapter responds to key questions surrounding theodicy and ethics, addressing critiques from anti-theodicists and exploring the relationship between divine justice, moral principles, and the problem of evil. The first question examines whether moral principles can be derived from a theodicy alone, concluding that theodicies do not directly map to specific moral views, and must be understood within broader theological and philosophical contexts. The second question challenges whether theodicy, by its nature, is harmful, with the argument that while theodicies carry risks, they need not inherently constitute harm if done cautiously, especially through a dissonant theodicy. The third question addresses whether God is a member of the moral community, proposing that God can be held to objective moral standards, contrary to the anti-theodicist position, through an understanding of goodness grounded in God’s nature or an external moral framework. The fourth question considers how a dissonant theodicy might shape ethical practice, suggesting an “ethics of dissonance” that acknowledges the tension between imitatio Dei and correctio Dei.