A Successful Outsider: Carl Stumpf as Philosopher and Scientist
摘要
Trained in classical philosophy, metaphysics, and logical reasoning under Brentano and Lotze, Stumpf also possessed an outstanding scientific education in mathematics and physics. His extensive body of work spans philosophy and phenomenology, as well as experimental research in psychology, including acoustic and musical phenomena, child psychology, animal psychology, the psychology of genius, and numerous other areas. In his epistemological writings, Stumpf proposes that philosophy and scientific practice should be mutually complementary, going beyond mere speculation to establish factual truths through experimentation. He specifies that this approach should include the hard sciences and not just the humanities. While these ideas secured him a successful professorship in Berlin, they also placed him as an outsider among philosophers, particularly in the phenomenological movement. This facet of Stumpf’s thinking may exhibit a surprising modernity that justifies reconsideration presently.