This chapter explores the evolution of religious representation in Hallmark films, focusing on how the network’s Christian roots have shaped its portrayal of diverse faiths. Although Hallmark officially became nonreligious in 2001, Christian influences, especially during the Christmas season, have remained strong. The chapter traces Hallmark’s shift from predominantly Christian content to a broader inclusion of holidays like Hanukkah, Kwanzaa, and Hindu festivals. While Hallmark has made strides in featuring diverse religious traditions, these portrayals are often crafted to appeal to a primarily Christian audience. Christian holidays and traditions, especially Christmas, still dominate, implicitly positioning Christianity as the norm. Other faiths, such as Judaism, are often portrayed in a didactic manner, either educating non-Jewish characters or reconnecting Jewish characters with their heritage, sometimes creating an “othering” effect. Kwanzaa, as depicted in Holiday Heritage (2022), stands out for its more authentic representation of African American culture, while Hindu rituals in Make Me a Match (2023) are treated as curiosities, perpetuating stereotypes. The chapter evaluates Hallmark’s progress and limitations in achieving religious pluralism. While the network has expanded its content, portrayals often remain confined by familiar narrative structures and commercialized interpretations of religious holidays, posing challenges for more accurate and respectful depictions.