Background <p>Previous studies have shown that upward bullying affects both organizational efficiency and the harmony of the work environment. However, the prevalence of upward bullying and its contributory factors remain unclear in Chinese nurse managers. This study aimed to explore the prevalence of upward bullying and its contributory factors as experienced by nurse managers in Chinese healthcare settings, together with an investigation of their specific experiences.</p> Methods <p>This study used a comprehensive, sequential, explanatory mixed methods design. The research was carried out in 12 provinces of China and included nurse managers working from various healthcare settings. The data collection involved an online survey completed by 210 nurse managers during the quantitative phase, followed by 17 semi-structured interviews during the qualitative phase. Our comprehensive approach, using both quantitative and qualitative methods, allowed us to gain a deep understanding of the prevalence and experiences of upward bullying among nurse managers, providing a robust foundation for our findings.</p> Results <p>Overall, 24.76% of nurse managers reported experiences of upward bullying and 40.38% of cases were classified as severe. Their upward bullying experiences were classified into nine categories and refined into four themes (perception of upward bullying by nurse managers, facilitators of upward bullying, calls for organizational support, and recovery and growth).</p> Conclusions <p>A considerable proportion of nurse managers in China experience upward bullying, which affects their physical and mental health and management effectiveness, impacting healthcare quality. Developing a supportive environment emphasizing respect, open communication, and professional development is crucial to mitigate upward bullying. Such a setting can help nurse managers cope with upward bullying and improve work culture.</p>

错误:搜索内容不能为空,请输入英文关键词
错误:关键词超出字数限制,请精简
高级检索

The prevalence and experience of upward bullying of nurse managers in China: a multicenter mixed methods survey

  • Shuang Wang,
  • Jia He,
  • Qin Cao,
  • Yang Liu,
  • Zining Zhang

摘要

Background

Previous studies have shown that upward bullying affects both organizational efficiency and the harmony of the work environment. However, the prevalence of upward bullying and its contributory factors remain unclear in Chinese nurse managers. This study aimed to explore the prevalence of upward bullying and its contributory factors as experienced by nurse managers in Chinese healthcare settings, together with an investigation of their specific experiences.

Methods

This study used a comprehensive, sequential, explanatory mixed methods design. The research was carried out in 12 provinces of China and included nurse managers working from various healthcare settings. The data collection involved an online survey completed by 210 nurse managers during the quantitative phase, followed by 17 semi-structured interviews during the qualitative phase. Our comprehensive approach, using both quantitative and qualitative methods, allowed us to gain a deep understanding of the prevalence and experiences of upward bullying among nurse managers, providing a robust foundation for our findings.

Results

Overall, 24.76% of nurse managers reported experiences of upward bullying and 40.38% of cases were classified as severe. Their upward bullying experiences were classified into nine categories and refined into four themes (perception of upward bullying by nurse managers, facilitators of upward bullying, calls for organizational support, and recovery and growth).

Conclusions

A considerable proportion of nurse managers in China experience upward bullying, which affects their physical and mental health and management effectiveness, impacting healthcare quality. Developing a supportive environment emphasizing respect, open communication, and professional development is crucial to mitigate upward bullying. Such a setting can help nurse managers cope with upward bullying and improve work culture.