Granitic melts derived from anatexis of metasedimentary rocks, particularly biotite-dehydration reactions, are important lithium (Li) sources. Petrogenetic models depend on mineral-melt lithium partitioning, yet published partition coefficients ( \({D}_{{{{\rm{Li}}}}}^{{{{\rm{mineral/melt}}}}}\) ) vary by over an order of magnitude, and are commonly used as static values. Here we use thermodynamic modelling coupled with relevant published \({D}_{{{{\rm{Li}}}}}^{{{{\rm{mineral/melt}}}}}\) ranges, including a dynamic composition- and temperature-dependent \({D}_{{{{\rm{Li}}}}}^{{{{\rm{biotite/melt}}}}}\) , to quantify viable enrichment during partial melting and fractional crystallisation. Using the lithium-rich Cornubian granite batholith, we demonstrate the sensitivity of results to \({D}_{{{{\rm{Li}}}}}^{{{{\rm{mineral/melt}}}}}\) choices for modally-dominant lithium-poor phases (e.g. quartz), as well as phases traditionally thought to dominate lithium budgets (e.g. biotite). While economic lithium enrichment can result from extreme fractionation with selective \({D}_{{{{\rm{Li}}}}}^{{{{\rm{mineral/melt}}}}}\) , we suggest that dehydration melting of fluorinated biotite is the most viable petrogenetic model. The latter reconciles the common observations of fluorite in lithium-granites and their late-orogenic occurrence, and provides a mechanism for extensive fractionation.