Next generation of non-contact and wireless vital sign monitoring technology in the neonatal intensive care unit: a systematic review
摘要
Current vital sign monitoring uses skin sensors connected to monitors via wires. Emerging technologies include non-contact and wireless wearable systems. This systematic review aims to determine the current stage of development of these technologies and the prospect for clinical translation.
MethodsA search on Medline, Embase, Cochrane, Scopus, and Engineering Village was conducted for studies published between January 2014 and August 2024. Two reviewers independently screened articles and extracted data on technology, signals and feasibility, safety, and accuracy outcomes. Risk of bias was assessed using the QUADAS-2; quantitative and qualitative analyses were conducted.
ResultsSixty observational studies were included: 43 (72%) non-contact and 17 (28%) wireless sensors. All used a reference sensor, with a median sample of 10 patients (IQR: 6–29); and median participant characteristics were moderately preterm infants around 34 weeks of age (IQR: 31–35). Studies typically monitored a single vital sign using offline data processing with good accuracy. Risk of bias and applicability concerns were driven by small samples, unclear participant selection, and limited reporting.
ConclusionNext generation non-contact and wireless wearable technologies have the potential to enhance neonatal vital sign monitoring, but research addressing limitations and exploring feasibility and safety are needed. Standardized reporting frameworks and greater transparency are necessary for comparisons across studies.
ImpactMost emerging technologies are non-contact technologies monitoring one vital sign, usually respiratory rate (RR), and a minority were wireless wearable sensors monitoring more than one vital sign usually heart rate and RR and showed good accuracy. Studies had small sample sizes, short recording durations, and exclusively focused on accuracy, and often missing important information about participants and study methodology. Wireless and non-contact technologies show promise, and this review provides recommendations to improve study design, extend recording durations, and enhance transparency in reporting and participant selection.