<p>I offer a positive argument in defense of the moral permissibility of abortion that relies on the moral concept of self-defense. I argue that given the lack of proportional self-defense options in pregnancy, a pregnant woman is morally permitted to procure a self-defensive abortion so long as the risks/burdens of her pregnancy and childbirth reach a sufficiently high threshold of seriousness. I then argue that even standard pregnancies reach this threshold, because of the expected physical and nonphysical risks/burdens imposed. Finally, I consider three objections—an objection based on the risks/burdens of abortion, an objection based on the fetus’s status as an innocent aggressor, and an objection based on the pregnant woman’s moral responsibility for the creation of the fetus.</p>

错误:搜索内容不能为空,请输入英文关键词
错误:关键词超出字数限制,请精简
高级检索

A Defense of Abortion on the Basis of Self-defense

  • Timothy Kirschenheiter

摘要

I offer a positive argument in defense of the moral permissibility of abortion that relies on the moral concept of self-defense. I argue that given the lack of proportional self-defense options in pregnancy, a pregnant woman is morally permitted to procure a self-defensive abortion so long as the risks/burdens of her pregnancy and childbirth reach a sufficiently high threshold of seriousness. I then argue that even standard pregnancies reach this threshold, because of the expected physical and nonphysical risks/burdens imposed. Finally, I consider three objections—an objection based on the risks/burdens of abortion, an objection based on the fetus’s status as an innocent aggressor, and an objection based on the pregnant woman’s moral responsibility for the creation of the fetus.