<p>Bioplastics offer a promising opportunity to reduce reliance on finite fossil fuel resources and mitigate carbon emissions. However, the integration of bioplastics into existing waste management systems presents distinct challenges, particularly in their interaction with organic waste streams and the complexities of disposal. This research explores the multifaceted issues associated with bioplastic waste management, focusing on contamination, the inefficiencies in sorting systems, and the restricted recycling infrastructure. The contamination of organic waste streams is a significant concern, as bioplastics often coexist with traditional plastics and non-compostable materials, complicating the recycling and disposal processes. Public attitudes and behaviours also play a critical role in waste segregation practices, with the need for improved education and awareness to ensure proper disposal of bioplastics. Dealing with the double dilemma of bioplastics as a substitute to traditional plastics and their ability to break down into microplastics (MPs), the study seeks to provide vital insights for legislators and waste managers. It emphasises the growing environmental issues related to bioplastic-derived MPs, which includes their persistence in soil, water, and the surrounding environment, where they could disturb ecosystems, pollute food chains, and affect biodiversity. The research emphasises the requirement of thorough waste management plans that not only support the use of bioplastics but also help to minimise these unwanted effects. This research is unique in that it provides a comprehensive evaluation of bioplastics' environmental impact, bridging the gap between their apparent sustainability and the underlying issues of degradation. In this perspective, the integration of bioplastics into sustainable waste management systems necessitates concerted efforts to reduce microplastic pollution, improve recycling facilities, and promote appropriate disposal methods.</p> Graphical abstract <p></p>