The impact of substituting clarified butter with canola oil on the components of metabolic syndrome, fatty liver index, and insulin resistance among individuals diagnosed with metabolic syndrome: a quasi-experimental study

Clarified butter, contain harmful saturated and beneficial trans-fatty acids. Canola oil is a promising alternative to other oils for reducing saturated fat intake. This trial aimed to investigate the effects of replacing clarified butter with canola oil in patients with metabolic syndrome on various metabolic syndrome components, fatty liver index (FLI), and insulin resistance.

In this trial, 42 individuals with metabolic syndrome referred to the clinic in Imam Khomeini University Hospital in Urmia, Iran, were enrolled. The participants, who commonly consumed (3 to 8 serving per day) clarified butter, were instructed to follow a healthy diet and replace their consumption of clarified butter with an equivalent amount of canola oil for 3 months. To compare the differences of outcomes in the group, the paired samples T-test and cohen’s d effect size were applied. To analyze the changes in dietary intakes and Metabolic equivalent of task (MET), repeated measures of ANOVA was used.

There was a significant decrease in fasting blood sugar (FBS) (< 0.001), triglyceride (TG) (0.003), and anthropometric measurements (< 0.001). Furthermore, significant reductions were observed in total cholesterol (TC) (< 0.001), low-density lipoprotein (LDL) (0.009), gamma-glutamyl transferase (GGT) levels (0.003), FLI (< 0.001), insulin levels (0.007), and homeostatic model assessment for insulin resistance (HOMA-IR) (0.002), and increase in quantitative insulin-sensitivity check index (QUICKI) (< 0.001). Unfavorably, there was a significant reduction in the high-density lipoprotein (HDL) (< 0.001).

The replacement of clarified butter with canola oil demonstrated potential benefits in improving metabolic syndrome.