Dependency-based FMEA model for product risk analysis: a case study of a switch mode power supply

The robustness of components/products/systems is a concern for both the company that sells them and the consumers who use them. Failure Modes and Effect Analysis (FMEA) which has evolved over 60 years, is a powerful and effective risk identification tool for both design and manufacturing, often combined with Multiple Criteria Decision-Making methods to increase its utility. However, most previous FMEA studies have neglected the interdependence of the failure modes. To address this issue, this study develops a novel method, the TEchnique for Defining the Influential Relationship of Failure Modes, to determine the risk prioritization of the failure modes. The interaction among failure modes is effectively identified and incorporated into the model. The primary analysis procedure can be divided into three parts: (i) the assessment of the initial risk scores of the failure modes; (ii) the definition of the degree of interdependence among the failure modes; and (iii) the integration of the final risk scores based on dependency. The model is used to conduct a case study for a multinational manufacturer of switch mode power supplies as a demonstration case. The practicality of the proposed model was validated through model comparisons and expert feedback. The results show that “an unstable output voltage”, “no power-good signal”, “recession in efficiency”, “burning out of components”, and “the cooling fan does not operate” are the top five risky failure modes. The research findings can be used as the basis for improvement strategies in R&D design and by quality assurance departments to enhance product reliability.