The Reach of Legal Cynicism: A Comment on Tommie Shelby’s The Idea of Prison Abolition
摘要
In The Idea of Abolition, Tommie Shelby traces the prison abolition movement in the U.S. to 1960s Black radical politics, a politics based in war metaphors and isolationist anti-state ideology. While an understandable response to government persecution of mid-twentieth century Black activists, anti-state ideology is a poor fit for the Black communities of the present. Something similar can be said about a prison abolition politics that broadly rejects the notion that criminal detention has a role to play—however limited—within the broader project of rehabilitating beleaguered Black residential communities.