Long-term exclusive organic fertilization sustains high vegetable yield but increases phosphorus saturation and dissolved P runoff risk in the Erhai Lake Basin
摘要
Securing high vegetable yields while mitigating environmental risks remains a critical challenge in subtropical plateau agroecosystems, particularly in the Erhai Lake Basin of China.
MethodsA 17-year field experiment was conducted with six treatments: no fertilization (CK), conventional fertilization (CON), organic manure alone (OM), combined organic–inorganic fertilization (NPK + OM), and NPK + OM with extra N (NPK + OM+N) or extra P (NPK + OM+P) We evaluated yield stability, soil N/P dynamics and losses, P mineral forms (XRD), heavy metal accumulation, and yield drivers via random forest and PLS-PM.
ResultsOM achieved the highest and most stable yield (CV 7.09%), with cumulative N balance (245.48 kg ha− 1) significantly lower than CON (727.06 kg ha− 1, p < 0.05) and cumulative P balance (624.29 kg ha− 1) comparable to CON. XRD revealed that most accumulated P in OM-treated soil was bound with Fe and Zn into stable minerals (Fe2(PO4)OH, Zn3(PO4)2). However, OM also caused excessive Olsen-P (171.32 mg kg− 1) and runoff dissolved P (1.31 mg L− 1), exceeding environmental thresholds. Random forest identified cumulative N balance as the key yield driver (optimal range 300–400 kg ha− 1); OM fell slightly below this range, whereas CON and NPK + OM+N exceeded it. PLS-PM indicated that nutrient accumulation positively associated with yield (0.36) but also increased runoff losses, while heavy metals showed a negative association (− 0.37). Heavy metals remained below safety thresholds after 17 years, but progressive accumulation in OM and CON signals long-term risk.
ConclusionsLong-term exclusive organic fertilization achieves high yield and N efficiency but causes P saturation and elevated dissolved P runoff, posing a high non-point source pollution risk. Sole organic fertilization is not recommended in the Erhai Lake Basin; optimizing combined fertilization with a higher organic N proportion is needed to balance productivity and environmental risk.