Does the tail wag the dog? Directional information effects of options trading on earnings management
摘要
This study examines the role of options trading in influencing the production of information in relation to earnings management practices. Options trading can impact information quality by increasing the speed and likelihood at which distorted earnings are uncovered by the market. We find a significantly negative relationship between options trading activity and both accrual-based earnings management and real earnings management. We further demonstrate that the effects of options trading vary by option type: call and put options have distinct directional implications. Specifically, the put-to-call options ratio is negatively associated with earnings management. For firms engaging in income-increasing earnings management, put option volume mitigates such behavior, while call option volume similarly curbs income-decreasing earnings manipulation. These results suggest that options trading functions as an external monitoring mechanism that enhances the transparency of financial reporting and disciplines management’s earnings manipulation practices.