Scholarlink

<p>In a recent paper, Perez Brower (2024) argues that identity framing of policy agendas shapes women’s willingness to become more politically involved. She conducts two survey experiments to examine whether intersectional identity framing—messaging by advocacy organizations that links policy issues to individuals’ multiple identity characteristics—alters self-reported political engagement and disengagement. Our re-evaluation of Perez Brower’s (2024) data and analysis reveals an omitted control group, miscoding of one dependent variable, and the selective reporting of outcomes from analyses, including omissions of results which the author preregistered. Correcting these errors undermines, either partially or completely, all of the findings from Perez Brower (2024). Our investigation underscores the importance of preregistration, data replication, and public availability of replication materials and experimental documentation for reliable social science research.</p>

错误：搜索内容不能为空，请输入英文关键词
错误：关键词超出字数限制，请精简
高级检索

Irregularities in Perez Brower (2024), “Reframing Gendered Issues: Intersectional Identity Frames and Policy Agendas”

  • 期刊论文

  • 发表日期：

    2026年7月24日

查看全文
  • Christopher Adolph,
  • Caitlin Ainsley,
  • Aslı Cansunar

摘要

In a recent paper, Perez Brower (2024) argues that identity framing of policy agendas shapes women’s willingness to become more politically involved. She conducts two survey experiments to examine whether intersectional identity framing—messaging by advocacy organizations that links policy issues to individuals’ multiple identity characteristics—alters self-reported political engagement and disengagement. Our re-evaluation of Perez Brower’s (2024) data and analysis reveals an omitted control group, miscoding of one dependent variable, and the selective reporting of outcomes from analyses, including omissions of results which the author preregistered. Correcting these errors undermines, either partially or completely, all of the findings from Perez Brower (2024). Our investigation underscores the importance of preregistration, data replication, and public availability of replication materials and experimental documentation for reliable social science research.