Testing Effect of Animation and Laboratory-Based Instructions on Pre-service Biology Teachers’ Achievement in Introductory Microbiology
摘要
Resource-based instructions such as animation and laboratory-based methods are of crucial importance to teachers and students in teaching and learning across the globe. However, these methods are often underutilized, and when utilized, laboratory-based methods are used in large-group settings, limiting individual active participation and performance. Therefore, this study tested the effect of animations and small-group laboratory activities on pre-service biology teachers’ academic achievement. The study used a quasi-experimental non-equivalent group, pre- and post-test control group design. Two experimental groups and one control group were used. The control group (N = 60) was taught by lecture method, the first experimental group (N = 55) by animation-based instruction, and the second experimental group (N = 59) by small-group laboratory activities. The data were collected using a Pre-service Biology Teachers Achievement Test, which showed a reliability of .51. We found that both lecture method, animation-based instruction, and laboratory methods using small-group laboratory activities improved pre-service biology teacher academic achievement with a very high statistically significant difference (p < .001). However, a repeated-measures analysis of covariance (ANCOVA) revealed a very high statistically significant difference raised by small-group laboratory activities among other teaching interventions. Therefore, based on their significant contributions and their high effect sizes, method specifically small-group laboratory activities are recommended to improve pre-service biology teachers’ academic achievement in biology.