<p>In order to gain a greater understanding of what life is like for physicians and medical trainees experiencing mental illness, six book-length memoirs written by physicians and trainees were analyzed via thematic analysis. All exhibited elements of a recovery narrative. We then queried our data to explore two specific questions we felt would be of special interest to our audience along with a discussion of relevant literature to place our findings in context: (1) What factors are involved in the mental illness recovery journey of physicians and trainees? (2) What stressors do physicians and trainees face as part of their career that may impact how they experience their mental illness? Our analyses revealed that the authors’ recovery journeys were fostered by mental health treatment, social supports, religion and/or spirituality, and personality traits. Physicians and trainees both experienced career stressors that impacted their mental health, and these stressors highlighted important issues such as barriers to treatment, medical licensure policies, and stigma. This study provides greater insight into not only some of the challenges of living with mental illness as a physician or trainee but also into what made recovery possible for them and how we might be able to support those who are struggling in the future. Discussing these important topics will hopefully reduce stigma for those experiencing mental illness and potentially influence public policy, specifically around de-stigmatizing physician licensure applications.</p>