A Qualitative Study of the Treatment Experiences of Autistic Adults Allocated to Sertraline or Placebo for Anxiety in a Blinded Randomised Controlled Trial
摘要
The STRATA randomised-controlled trial (RCT) examined the antidepressant sertraline vs placebo for treating anxiety in autistic adults. Autistic people are often assumed to be reluctant to take part in RCTs due to intolerance of their inherent uncertainty. This study aimed to qualitatively examine autistic people’s experiences of RCT participation, specifically regarding their random assignment to an antidepressant (sertraline) or placebo for their mental health, whilst blinded to treatment allocation.
MethodsSemi-structured interviews were undertaken with a purposive sample of 62 STRATA participants. The interviews examined why they chose to take part, why they continued in the trial and/or discontinued medication, and their overall experience of participation. Interviews took place either during participation, or at participants’ final trial appointment at 52-weeks post randomisation (‘exit interviews’). Data were analysed thematically through a collaborative process, with multiple researchers independently coding, discussing, and refining themes.
ResultsInterviewees often discussed improved anxiety, attributing changes to believing they were taking sertraline, experiencing the placebo effect, or external factors. Post-analysis unblinding revealed that improved anxiety was discussed equally by participants in both the sertraline and placebo groups. Some participants, including those taking placebo, experienced side effects, which mirrored the types, frequency, and severity seen in the general population. Many were able to manage these and continue, but some discontinued medication as a result.
ConclusionAspects of trial design and delivery facilitated continuation with the study medication, including frequent appointments, shared control over medication dose, and meaningfully involving autistic people in trial design. Such non-pharmacological factors may enhance therapeutic benefits, and may improve RCT design and therapeutic alliances with autistic people.