<p>Whether phenotypic plasticity facilitates adaptive evolution is a key question in evolutionary ecology. The discovery of limb-length plasticity in two <i>Anolis</i> lizard species led to hypotheses about its role in the <i>Anolis</i> radiation. Yet, whether limb plasticity is realized in nature and has adaptive significance is poorly understood. In this study, we combined a limb-length plasticity experiment, lab-based assays of hatchling behavior, and field-based measures of individual perch-diameter use of hatchling <i>A. sagrei</i>. We compared our findings to previous lab experiments and field studies to better understand the ecological conditions that might elicit limb plasticity and influence the adaptive potential of limb-length in <i>Anolis</i> lizards. Results from our lab experiment did not support limb-length plasticity. Significant limb-length differences due to plasticity were found in some previous experiments but not others. Intriguingly, repeated observations of individual hatchlings at night revealed consistent use of narrow-diameter perches for an island population. In contrast, individual diurnal perch-diameter use in adult <i>A. sagrei</i> was much less uniform. Little evidence exists for adaptive behavior or performance in hatchlings related to limb length and perch diameters. Several aspects of anole behavior and ecology, such as perch preferences and sleep-site use, influence perch-diameter use. Differences among populations in hindlimb length for Bahamian islands often exceed the average plastic response found in lab experiments. Evidence for the ecological relevance and adaptive potential of limb-length plasticity in <i>Anolis</i> lizards is currently mixed. A better understanding of how perch-diameter use results in biomechanical and developmental cues that influence limb growth is needed. The lack of clear support from lab and field studies urges caution when hypothesizing about the role of limb-length plasticity in the <i>Anolis</i> radiation.</p>