Effect of test distance on refraction bias at 3 m, 5 m, and optical 5 m, compared with 20 m
摘要
To quantify accommodation-related bias in objective refraction measured at 3 m, 5 m, and an optical 5 m space-saving chart (SSC) relative to a 20 m reference, and to evaluate simple distance-specific corrections to obtain 20 m-equivalent values.
MethodsEighteen healthy adults with myopia (20–29 years; right eyes) underwent open-field autorefractor measurements (WAM-5500). At 20 m, over-refraction was performed in 0.05 diopter (D) increments, adjusting the sphere/cylinder values as close to 0.00 D as possible. Refraction was recorded at 5 m, 3 m, and optical 5 m (SSC-370) in a randomized order. Ten readings per condition were averaged. The primary outcome was spherical equivalent (SE). Bland–Altman bias and 95% limits of agreement (LoA) were estimated; secondary analyses compared shift magnitudes among short distances.
ResultsMean (± standard deviation) SE was − 0.030 ± 0.047 D (20 m), − 0.212 ± 0.032 D (5 m), − 0.342 ± 0.023 D (3 m), and − 0.225 ± 0.037 D (SSC). Myopic shifts versus 20 m were significant (all p < 0.001). LoA were − 0.285 to − 0.081 (5 m), − 0.413 to − 0.211 (3 m), and − 0.314 to − 0.077 (SSC). The 3 m shift exceeded that of 5 m and SSC (both p < 0.001); the shifts at 5 m and SSC did not differ (p = 0.31).
ConclusionsShorter test distances introduce a systematic myopic bias in objective refraction, being the greatest at 3 m; 5 m and SSC (optical 5 m) are comparable. Applying distance-specific constant corrections may allow practical conversion to 20 m-equivalent values.