Body mass index in pediatric kidney transplant selection criteria

Obesity is associated with increased complications, rejection, and graft loss after kidney transplantation in adult and pediatric recipients. Elevated body mass index (BMI) is a common contraindication to transplant at adult kidney transplant programs; however, there is no data on such limitations for pediatric patients.

Between October and December 2022, we conducted a survey of Pediatric Nephrology Research Consortium centers assessing the use of BMI in pediatric kidney transplant evaluation. Centers reporting utilization of BMI cutoffs were invited to submit patient-level data on children declined for active transplant listing due to BMI.

Thirty-nine centers responded to the survey (42% response rate); 51% include BMI in their written listing criteria, with a median BMI “cutoff” of 39 kg/m² (range 30–50 kg/m²). Between January 1, 2016, and December 31, 2021, 30 children at 15 transplant centers were declined for listing status due to BMI. Patient-level data was provided for 19 children (63%) who were denied active listing status; median BMI was 42 kg/m² (range 35.8–49.4 kg/m²) and 84% were on dialysis. One year after evaluation, seven patients (37%) had proceeded to active wait list status. Eight (42%) remained in inactive status and four (21%) were unlisted; ten of these 12 patients (83%) were on dialysis.

The use of BMI in pediatric kidney transplant evaluation and listing varies among centers, but BMI limits access to transplant for some children. More information is needed on the outcomes of obese pediatric kidney candidates who are and are not transplanted, to guide development of national and international consensus.