Let \(\mathbb {S}_h\) denote a sphere with h holes. Given a triangulation G of a surface \(\mathbb {M}\) , we consider the question of when G contains a spanning subgraph H such that H is a triangulated \(\mathbb {S}_h\) . We give a new short proof of a theorem of Nevo and Tarabykin [15] that every triangulation G of the torus contains a spanning subgraph which is a triangulated cylinder. For arbitrary surfaces, we prove that every high facewidth triangulation of a surface with h handles contains a spanning subgraph which is a triangulated \(\mathbb {S}_{2h}\) . We also prove that for every \(0 \le g' < g\) and \(w \in \mathbb {N}\) , there exists a triangulation of facewidth at least w of a surface of Euler genus g that does not have a spanning subgraph which is a triangulated \(\mathbb {S}_{g'}\) . Our results are motivated by, and have applications for, rigidity questions in the plane.