Current availability and status of paediatric cardiac transplantation and mechanical circulatory support in twenty-eight European countries
摘要
We sought to investigate the inter- and intra-country variation in paediatric heart transplantation (HTx) and mechanical circulatory support (MCS) availability and practice in Europe. Data was obtained through a survey circulated to paediatric transplant cardiologists identified through the Association of European Paediatric and Congenital Cardiology between November 2022 and March 2023. Twenty-eight respondents from twenty-eight European countries completed the survey. Twenty-four (86%) had paediatric and 25 (89%) had adult congenital HTx services. National paediatric HTx centre density ranged from 0.00 to 5.35 per 10 million inhabitants. Eighteen (64%) countries followed either Eurotransplant or Scandiatransplant protocols for organ allocation and 59% of the surveyed countries had low HTx volumes (< 4 paediatric HTx annually), based on the self-reported numbers. A ventricular assist device (VAD) programme was operational in 22 (79%) countries. In only 9 countries (38%), there were dedicated resources for HTx as part of the hospital budget; however, a vast majority (77%) reported that families suffered no cost when a VAD was utilised. Twenty-one countries (78%) reported limited intensive care unit beds and 14 (54%) reported that HTx impacted on congenital heart surgery cases. Only 12 of 27 countries (44%) had a standardised national protocol for post-HTx care. There was no correlation between paediatric HTx centre density, population or GDP per capita.
Conclusion: There is a high degree of variation both within and between the surveyed European countries with regard to paediatric HTx centre density, VAD availability, listing protocols, and post-HTx management. Multiple factors contribute to this heterogeneity, which makes standardisation of HTx listing and VAD criteria challenging. Increased cross-national collaborative efforts between European countries may strengthen both HTx and MCS availability and outcomes, especially in regions with several smaller neighbouring countries.