Exploring the competency of the comprehensive complication index over the clavien–dindo classification in standard percutaneous nephrolithotomy: a call for better complication reporting

The Comprehensive Complication Index (CCI) was introduced in 2013 to overcome the limitations of the Clavien–Dindo Classification (CDC) in grading postoperative complications. The objective of this study to assess the predictive value of the CDC and the CCI for postoperative course in patients undergoing standard adult percutaneous nephrolithotomy (PCNL).

A retrospective analysis of 320 renal units that underwent standard PCNL between July 2021 - April 2023 was conducted. The CDC and CCI systems assessed complications occurring within the first 30 days after surgery. A second CCI score was calculated only on the highest CDC grade, and this score was referred to as the noncumulative CCI. A comparative analysis was conducted to determine the predictive efficacy of both evaluation methods regarding the postoperative course.

The postoperative complication rate was 23.1% (74/320). Eight patients (2.5%) experienced multiple complications, resulting in a higher total CCI score than the noncumulative CCI (p = 0.010). Correlation analysis revealed that the CCI correlated with the length of hospital stay (LOS) more precisely than the noncumulative CCI (CCI: r = 0.335; p = 0.004 vs. noncumulative CCI: r = 0.325; p = 0.005). Compared with patients with a single complication, those with multiple complications had similar demographics, preoperative stone characteristics, and intraoperative features.

Cumulative CCI proves to be a more effective predictor of LOS and complication burden in standard PCNL than CDC. Hence, using CCI to evaluate complications after PCNL may be a more appropriate approach.