Bone marrow edema-like signal after cartilage repair does not affect outcomes in a five-year follow-up

Bone marrow edema-like signal (BMELS) after cartilage repair is common, but its clinical significance remains uncertain. This study aimed to investigate the clinical and structural significance of BMELS following microfracturing (MFX) and matrix-induced autologous chondrocyte implantation (MACI).

In this multicenter study, MRI examinations were performed over a period of 5 years after cartilage repair surgery (MFX n = 17; MACI n = 28) in 45 patients. Morphological assessments, including the MOCART 2.0 (magnetic resonance observation of cartilage repair tissue), quantitative imaging biomarkers (QIB) with T2 mapping of the repair tissue, and, specifically, assessment of the presence and size of BMELS, were conducted along with patient-reported outcome measures, such as the Knee injury and Osteoarthritis Outcome Score (KOOS) and the International Knee Documentation Committee (IKDC). BMELS structural and clinical assessments were obtained after 3 months, 12 months, and 60 months. Statistical analysis included the Mann–Whitney U-test, Wilcoxon rank test, Shapiro–Wilk test, and simulation-based power analysis.

BMELS were a common finding 60 months after cartilage repair. The size of BMELS differed significantly only between MACI and MFX patients after 3 months, with larger BMELS occurring in the MFX group. There were no significant differences in patients with or without BMELS regarding the T2 ratio of the treated area, the MOCART 2.0, or clinical scores.

BMELS frequently appeared after cartilage repair procedures. We could show that the postoperative size and change in the size of BMELS after MACI and MFX did not affect clinical scores, morphological MRI results, or biochemical properties of the treated area after 60 months.

Question What is the clinical significance of bone marrow edema-like signal (BMELS) appearance after matrix-induced autologous chondrocyte implantation (MACI) or microfracture (MFX)?

Finding There were no significant differences in patients with or without BMELS regarding the T2 ratio of the treated area, the MOCART 2.0, or clinical scores.

Clinical relevance BMELS frequently appeared after cartilage repair, the appearance or the size dynamic after MACI and MFX did not affect clinical scores, morphological MRI results, or biochemical properties after 60 months.