In this paper, we first construct a sequence of hyperbolic surfaces with connected geodesic boundary such that the first normalized Steklov eigenvalue \(\tilde{\sigma }_1\) tends to infinity. We then prove that the Weil–Petersson probability that a hyperbolic surface \(\Sigma \) of genus g with n boundary components of lengths \(L_g^1, \ldots , L_g^n\) satisfies \(\tilde{\sigma }_1(\Sigma )>C\cdot \Vert L_g\Vert _1\) , where C is a positive universal constant, tends to 1 as \(g \rightarrow \infty \) , provided that \(\Vert L_g\Vert _1=\sum _{i=1}^n L_g^i\) tends to infinity at most logarithmically in g and each \(L_g^i\) stays away from zero.