Comparative toxicity of water-soluble fractions of crude oil, gasoline, diesel, insulating and lubricant mineral oil to a neotropical freshwater fish
摘要
We quantified the acute toxicity of water-soluble fractions (WSFs) from crude oil, gasoline, diesel, lubricant oil, and two insulating mineral oils (IMOa, IMOb) to the Neotropical fish Astyanax altiparanae. Six independent static-renewal assays (110 fish each; 11 nominal WSF dilutions [0–100% v/v]) were performed. The calculated LC50-96 h and LC10-96 h were gasoline = 2.65 and 0.5%; diesel = 16.22 and 2.75%; IMOa = 17.01 and 5.35%; petroleum = 23.59 and 1.76%; lubricant = 27.65 and 11.24%; and IMOb = 53.58 and 7.84%. Gasoline was the most toxic, reflecting its high BTEX and low-molecular-weight PAH content, whereas lubricant oil and IMOb were least toxic, consistent with their dominance of high-molecular-weight hydrocarbons. The unexpectedly high toxicity of IMOa, comparable to diesel, is likely attributable to proprietary antioxidant additives. These baseline LC50/LC10 data fill a gap for tropical freshwater species and provide reference points for subsequent sub-chronic testing and regional environmental-risk assessments. By establishing a clear toxicity hierarchy for common hydrocarbon contaminants and highlighting the overlooked role of additives, this work is crucial for developing scientific-grounded water quality guidelines tailored to protect the unique and often understudied biodiversity of neotropical freshwater ecosystems.